How IUDs for Temporary Contraception Can LeadHow IUDs for Temporary Contraception Can Lead

How IUDs for Temporary Contraception Can Lead to Permanent Infertility

A vital component of women’s healthcare is contraception, which gives them the ability to manage and plan their reproductive health. Most people consider long-term contraceptive methods—like copper IUDs—to be practical and effective. By giving women the freedom to choose when to get pregnant, these devices improve their quality of life.  

It is quite concerning, though, since some women who use these devices end up with serious and potentially harmful consequences. The major issue includes infertility. This blog post explores copper IUDs’ workings, efficacy, and possible hazards. It primarily addresses the Paragard IUD and its unsettling breaking incidents.

A Primer on Red Light Running and Automated Enforcement

The Goods, Bads, and Terribles of Copper IUDs

T-shaped copper IUDs, like Paragard, are placed into the uterus to prevent conception. They leak copper ions into the surroundings, which makes it poisonous for sperm and stops fertilization.  

The Better Health Channel notes that the copper IUD is made to last, and has efficacy of up to ten years. It is easily reversible. Fertility is usually quickly restored after removal, which makes it a desirable choice for people looking for short-term contraception. 

According to NIH data, copper IUDs have a failure rate of less than 1%, making them highly effective. However, they do have some hazards, much like other medical devices.  

While rare, device failure raises serious concerns. FDA data from 2022 showed that 1,231 Paragard IUD breaks resulted in difficulties for specific users, reported NBC News. Broken pieces of an IUD can become embedded in the uterus, causing excruciating pain, infection, and infertility in certain situations.

A Case of Concern Posed by Paragard IUD

The Paragard IUD has demonstrated a greater frequency of device breakage among the currently on the market. This is proved by data from the Archives of Obstetrics and Gynecology. The concern has prompted the high-profile Paragard lawsuit against the manufacturer. Moreover, the brand is accused of producing a gadget prone to breaking and seriously injuring users. 

According to the latest data, over 6,000 cases of Paragard breakage have been filed to the FDA since 2021. 80% of which have had severe health consequences, reports FOX News. These cases underscore the pressing necessity for enhanced safety protocols and increased dissemination of hazards to prospective users.

Risks of Infertility from Paragard Use

Physical Damage to the Uterus

A 2024 study involving CT images of IUDs highlights that pieces of a broken Paragard IUD can harm the uterine wall. This might include cuts or punctures, both of which have the potential to leave scars. Adhesions may occur due to this scarring, which may alter the uterus’s natural shape and function.  

Unusual bands of scar tissue called adhesions have the ability to bind organs together and block fallopian tubes. As per Healthline, this blockage may hinder the movement of sperm and eggs, hindering spontaneous conception and leading to infertility.

Infection and Inflammation

Fragments of a broken IUD can transfer germs into the uterus, which can cause infections and persistent irritation. These pieces may provide bacteria with the perfect environment for reproduction, leading to localized illnesses. 

According to FPNSW, infections of this nature have the potential to spread to the ovaries and fallopian tubes. It leads to pelvic inflammatory disease (PID) if left untreated. PID is a dangerous illness that can harm reproductive organs. The complexity results in problems like obstructed fallopian tubes, which greatly raises the chance of infertility.

Surgical Complications

Surgical intervention may be required in severe cases to remove a damaged IUD, notes TorHoerman Law. Moreover, this procedure is not without danger. There’s a chance the uterus or other reproductive organs will sustain more harm throughout the process. Scarring, adhesions, or direct damage to the reproductive tissues are examples of surgical complications. 


 These abnormalities have the potential to impair the reproductive system’s regular operation and result in persistent fertility difficulties. It takes expert surgical techniques and careful supervision to reduce these dangers and protect reproductive health.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take for a copper IUD to be removed before fertility returns?

Usually, fertility returns the moment a copper IUD is removed. It is a practical alternative for individuals who expect to become pregnant quickly. However, note that while fertility can return rapidly, individual experiences may vary. It will depend on factors such as gender health, age, and previous fertility history.

How should my IUD be replaced if it breaks?

If your IUD breaks, you must seek prompt medical assistance to assess and treat any consequences. Your medical professional will examine the severity of the problem. They can suggest the best course of action to prevent future harm.

Are there any safer substitutes for Paragard?

Yes, there are contraceptive techniques and IUD choices that could be safer for you.  Lo Loestrin Fe and Mirena are two options to explore. Mirena is a hormonal IUD that releases progestin and can prevent pregnancy for up to 6 years. On the contrary, Lo Loestrin Fe is an oral contraceptive that combines estrogen and progestin. 

Is it always safe to remove an IUD that breaks?

  1. Most damaged IUDs may be safely removed, but occasionally surgery may be necessary, which has its own dangers. Your medical professional will assess your situation and choose the safest and most efficient removal technique. 

The potential of copper IUDs to offer permanent, reversible contraception is what makes them promising. Nonetheless, the dangers of device breakage—especially with the Paragard IUD—highlight the necessity of improved patient education and safety measures. Women ought to have the freedom to make decisions about their reproductive health without worrying about unfavorability like infertility.